Sunday, April 15, 2012
Dances With Wolves. . . Not
Recently, there has been controversy over the recent re-introduction of wolves into parts of the United States. These complaints come mainly at the behest of farmers and/or ranchers who feel that their livelihood, the livestock they raise and sell for various purposes. The wolves used to be on the list of Federally Endangered Species but were recently removed by Congress. This was the first time that Congress had directly intervened and removed a species from the Endangered List. This action has outraged many environmental groups for a couple reasons. First, they do not believe that the wolves were ready as a species, whether in terms of population or some other factor, to be released into the wild again. Second, they were not happy in that Congress stepped directly in and intervened in something that they probably didn't have the appropriate knowledge to be making decisions with. There has been a widespread public outrage at the release of these wolves into the wild. Many people feel that the wolves will be a danger to farmers' livestock and pets. So far there have not been many if any cases of livestock going missing and people blaming it on the recently re-introduced predators. The fact is, people are just afraid that they will become a problem if they start to hunt the livestock. Some people, afraid that the wolves will become a problem as stated above, have decided that seeing as the wolves are no longer on the Endangered Species List, the laws against hunting and trapping said animals don't necessarily apply any longer. People have started trapping animals and some pictures of dead and maimed wolves that appeared in the media and on social networking sites such as Facebook have caused quite a stir in the Mid-West. Many people have responded to these pictures with enthusiasm and sometimes even support for the actions of the hunters and trappers. The farmers and ranchers are afraid that the wolves will encroach on their property and kill their livestock but the simple fact of the mater is, the wolves were here long before the humans. The land we call our own, was theirs to begin with. They are not encroaching on the farmers' land, it's the other way around. People's views of wolves depends first and foremost where they are from and whether or not their occupations and assets are harmed by the wolves. I personally believe that the wolves have every right to live in their ancestral environment and we as humans have no right to push them out of that land. We are supposed to live in harmony with nature, not push it out.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I agree with you in the sense that these animals should not be hunted when they aren't even a threat at all. I guess my main concern is how they were being fed before being released and if they will even know how to hunt for food. As with the farmers and their live stock, just because the wolves have been released back into the wild doesn't mean they will be released necessarily any where near human life. And I was also concerned about the part of being integrated back into the wild. Are they really held in some kind of captivity when they are an endangered species? I guess I thought there were laws that prohibited the killing or tracking of the animals but I didn't realized that they were not allowed to live in their natural habitat.
ReplyDeleteI like the point that you bring up about how it's not technically our land in the first place. The fact that we're not natives of this land I feel is too often lost on people in today's society. Even more important that that, in my opinion, is the means by which we got (i.e. took) the land. The ways by which we obtained "our" land are ruthless, devious, and in many cases, just downright wrong and immoral. To say that we have control over the animals of a land that we obtained through merciless killing of the native peoples and "fair" treaties is just absurd in my mind. I think this whole conversation about the reintroduction of wolves into the wild shows that we need to take a step back and look at how much we are regulating this country, and maybe stop some of what we're doing and just let nature take it's course.
ReplyDeleteI also agree with you that it is the wolves’ land, not ours. But honestly I can see it from the farmers’ point of view too. They work hard to keep their livestock alive and healthy and safe from predators. On the other hand, it is the wolves’ natural right to live on that land. It is a natural instinct for them to hunt other animals. And if the farmers make it easier for the wolves to find food, then the wolves will keep coming back. You can’t keep an animal from going with its natural instincts and hunting the easily accessible livestock.
ReplyDelete